Don’t Fall for These Weight Loss Myths in 2024: The Truth About Weight Loss vs. Fat Loss

Fat loss and weight loss are not identical concepts.

They have different meanings, even though people often confuse them.

Weight loss is the number that shows up on the scale. It reflects the total mass of everything in your body … and when you lose weight, you reduce the amount of everything.

Fat loss on the other hand is the reduction of body fat — the soft tissue on your body. When you shed fat, you may look slimmer or more defined … but your weight may not change much.

Your goals determine if you need to lose weight and/or fat.

For example, a lower weight does not guarantee a fitter body. You can achieve a toned, ripped, or muscular physique without dropping as much weight as you expect (or maybe none at all).

Key takeaways

  • Fat loss and weight loss are not the same.
  • Shedding fat can boost your metabolic health.
  • Aiming for fat loss can help you achieve optimal results.
  • You can drop weight by shedding water, glycogen, muscle, bone, or fat. 
  • It is important to know what your goal is.

What is Weight Loss?

The Truth About Weight Loss: It’s Not What You Think! You might think that losing weight means losing fat. But that’s not always the case. Your body is full of different stuff, and you could be losing any of it.

  • Losing fat is awesome. It makes you look more ripped, your clothes hug your curves better, and your metabolism goes through the roof.
  • You could also lose muscle, which is not so great. That means your metabolism will slow down, you’ll have a harder time keeping your weight stable, you’ll be less strong, and you’ll be more prone to injuries.
  • Or you could lose water and/or glycogen, which is just temporary. Your water weight varies constantly, depending on your actions. Consuming a high-sodium meal or reducing your carbohydrate intake can affect it significantly.

You might wish you could just tell your body to burn all the energy from your fat, but that’s not how it works. When you shed pounds, you also lose some muscle as part of your Lean Body Mass along with your fat.

You probably want a lasting, visible, and quantifiable transformation in your physique. Am I right?

For that, you need to lose fat.


Weight Loss vs. Fat Loss
@Freepik

What is Fat Loss?

Body fat consists of two main components: essential fat and storage fat. Essential fat plays a vital role in the body’s functionality, while storage fat accumulates as energy reserves.

Fat loss is the process of reducing body fat. But how exactly does it work?

  • First:  intramuscular fat, which is mixed into your muscles. 
  • Second: visceral fat, the kind that wraps around your belly and your vital organs 
  • Third: subcutaneous fat, the kind that hangs out under your skin

Losing fat doesn’t always mean losing weight, depending on what else is going on in your body.

For example, if you’re building muscle with strength training while you’re losing body fat, your weight might stay the same or even go up (for instance, lose 1 lb of fat but gain 2 lbs of muscle).

What’s the difference between weight loss and fat loss?

To sum up the difference between weight loss and fat loss:

  • Weight loss is when your overall body weight goes down. 
  • Fat loss is when your body fat percentage goes down. 
  • When you lose weight, you could have lost water, muscle, fat, glycogen, or bone mass.
  • When you lose fat, you might lose weight too. Or you might stay the same or gain weight. 
  • Losing water, muscle, glycogen, or bone mass doesn’t make you healthier. 
  • Losing fat (within a healthy body fat range) lowers your risk of chronic diseases and boosts your metabolic health.

How do I know how much fat I’m losing?

When tracking fat loss, it’s essential to move beyond general weight measurements. While external indicators like scales, clothing fit, and tape measures are useful for overall weight loss, specifically assessing fat loss can be challenging. 

So, how can you tell if you’re losing fat weight vs. losing muscle weight or water weight?

Here are practical ways to estimate fat loss:

  1. Tape Measure: Don’t underestimate the traditional tape measure. Regularly measure your waist, arms, thighs, hips, and buttocks every two weeks. Remember that everyone’s body changes at different rates.
  1. Progress Pictures: Capture full-body progress photos consistently. Maintain the same position, lighting, and time of day for accurate comparisons.
  1. Clothing Fit: Pay attention to how well your clothes fit. The way your jeans fit can be a reliable indicator of progress.
  1. Calipers: While not for the faint-hearted, calipers provide accurate subcutaneous fat measurements. Keep in mind that they don’t capture stubborn visceral fat.
  1. Regular Scales: Bathroom scales still have value. Knowing your weight helps set and maintain targets. However, remember that weight alone doesn’t fully represent fat loss.

Remember that a holistic approach, combining multiple methods, provides a clearer picture of fat loss progress.

Why Should You Focus on Fat Loss and not Weight Loss?

Many people have negative perceptions about weight and associate it with health problems. However, pursuing weight loss as a goal can have harmful effects, such as developing eating disorders. 

A better way to improve health and well-being is to focus on fat loss and maintaining a balanced body composition. This means having a healthy ratio of fat and muscle in the body. This approach also motivates the individual to adopt a more active lifestyle and a nutritious diet.

There are good reasons to pursue the actions that lead to fat loss. These reasons are:

  • By focusing on the behaviors that improve your health, rather than the outcomes that measure it, you can develop lasting and beneficial habits. 
  • By tracking both fat loss and weight loss, you can see different types of progress and keep yourself motivated to continue your journey. 
  • By obsessing over a number on the scale, you can end up harming your body in various ways, such as depriving yourself of essential nutrients or overexerting yourself in the gym.

Shocking Difference Between Weight Loss and Fat Loss
@Freepik

How to Lose Fat and Maintain or Gain Muscle

Building muscle and losing body fat are complementary goals. This process of improving your body composition, also known as ‘getting lean’, may not be everyone’s priority, but if you want to learn how to build muscle and lose fat, keep reading!

The best way to lose fat and preserve muscle is to support your overall health and well-being.

You might think that you only want to reduce your body fat without gaining muscle… but did you know that even a slight increase in muscle mass can boost your metabolism? These tips to gain lean muscle will help you burn more calories at rest, which facilitates easier fat loss!

#1. Use challenging weights:

No matter if you’re doing sets of 6 reps or sets of 12 reps, the weights should be challenging enough that you can barely do one more rep in each set. Pushing the boundaries of your strength forces your body to adjust, which is crucial for gaining lean muscle.

#2. Practice interval training:

For cardio, interval training is the optimal way to lose fat and maintain muscle.

Interval training not only improves your fitness and speed, but it also boosts your metabolism. Sprints are intense, but they’re so short and efficient that doing them once or twice a week is sufficient to achieve excellent results.

#3. Consume adequate calories:

For nutrition, the best way to lose fat and preserve muscle is to avoid under-eating.

Starving is harmful, and thriving is beneficial! It may sound paradoxical, as it contradicts what the media has been promoting for too long… but if you provide your body with enough energy, with a balance of carbs, fats and protein – you’ll achieve a leaner, healthier and stronger body in the long run.

#4. Focus on stress management:

Did you know that stress can reduce your metabolism, hinder fat loss and impair muscle growth? The hormones associated with persistently high levels of stress can also make us gain more fat, retain more water, and even diminish some of the muscle mass we have.

#5. Sleep well:

It’s crucial for your fitness goals. If you want to enhance your fitness results, always prioritize your sleep. Sleep deprivation not only affects your exercise performance negatively, but it also impairs your body’s ability to heal and recover after a workout.


difference between weight loss and fat loss
@Freepik

How does your Metabolism Change with Weight Loss?

Metabolism is the process of turning food and drink into energy for your body. It affects how many calories you burn, even when you are not exercising. 

When you try to lose weight by eating less, your metabolism slows down to adjust to the lower calorie intake. This makes it harder to keep losing weight and easier to gain it back. 

To prevent this, you need to increase your physical activity and build more muscle mass, which burns more calories than fat. By doing this, you can boost your metabolism and achieve your weight loss goals in a healthy and sustainable way.

Key points to remember:

  • Metabolism is the rate at which your body expends energy or burns calories.
  • Metabolism depends on several factors, such as muscle mass, body size and composition, sex, age, and genes.
  • Metabolism slows down when you reduce your calorie intake, as a way to conserve energy.
  • Metabolism can be increased by increasing your physical activity and muscle mass, which will help you burn more calories and lose fat.
  • Metabolism is not the only factor that affects weight loss. You also need to consider your diet, lifestyle, hormones, and genetics.

The Bottom Line

Weight loss refers to a decrease in your overall body weight from muscle, water, and fat losses. Fat loss refers to weight loss that occurs specifically from losses in fat mass. To measure your fat loss, don’t rely on the scale. Use a body fat tester or a skinfold pinch instead.

Losing weight does not necessarily mean losing fat. Sometimes, people lose water and muscle, not just fat. This can have negative effects on health, such as lowered metabolism, fatigue, and increased risk of chronic diseases and age-related muscle loss. 

Losing fat, on the other hand, can improve health, as it reduces the fat-to-muscle ratio and lowers the risk of metabolic syndrome, heart disease, and diabetes.

To lose fat and maintain or gain muscle, some tips are:

  • Eating a balanced diet that is high in protein and fiber, and low in processed foods and added sugars.
  • Doing resistance training and aerobic exercise regularly to stimulate muscle growth and increase calorie burn.
  • Getting enough sleep and managing stress levels to optimize hormone balance and recovery.
  • Drinking plenty of water to stay hydrated and support metabolism.

Summary: Weight loss and fat loss are not the same thing. Fat loss is more beneficial than weight loss for health and body composition. To lose fat, it is important to eat well, exercise, and take care of yourself.


Frequently Asked Questions:

1. Can you lose fat without losing weight?

Yes, you can lose fat without losing weight if you gain muscle mass at the same time. Muscle is denser than fat, so it takes up less space in your body. This means you can look thinner and more toned even if your weight stays the same or increases slightly.

2. Does fat loss take longer than weight loss?

Fat loss usually takes longer than weight loss because it requires a smaller calorie deficit and more time to burn off stored fat. Weight loss can include losses from water, muscle, and glycogen, which can happen quickly, especially in the first few weeks of a diet.

3. How long until weight loss is noticed?

The time it takes to notice weight loss may depend on how much weight you lose, how you measure your progress, and how often you see yourself or others.

Generally, it may take about four weeks for others to notice weight loss and six to eight weeks for you to notice. However, you may notice changes in your clothes size or body fat percentage sooner.

4. Which part of the body is the hardest to lose fat?

The hardest part of the body to lose fat may vary depending on your genetics, gender, and age. However, some common areas that tend to store excess fat are the neck, back, chest, stomach, and hips & love handles. These areas may require more exercise and dietary changes to reduce fat.

5. Why do I look thinner but weigh more?

You may look thinner but weigh more if you have replaced body fat with lean muscle. Muscle is more compact than fat, so it makes you appear slimmer and more defined. However, muscle also weighs more than fat, so it can increase your weight or keep it stable.


References:

  1. https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/exercise-metabolism-and-weight-new-research-from-the-biggest-loser-202201272676
  2. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK572145/
  3. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3519150/
  4. https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/snooze-more-eat-less-sleep-deprivation-may-hamper-weight-control-202204042718
  5. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6566799/
  6. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5421125/

Leave a Comment